Posts by Anony Mous

129

Just because Jehovah had to prove His Right To Rule? I don't think so!

by liam in

we get old because jehovah had to prove to all the angels that his way of ruling was the best?

that's the sorriest argument the watchtower has come up with.

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/11hz_jqjkjo.

Anony Mous

I think the problem in (many) Christian religions is to attribute omnipotence to God, as if he has the capacity to solve the problem of evil and the second problem is an afterlife that is always good, regardless of your choices.

The Jewish view and some Christians also believe that evil only exists within us (humans) and it is a choice we make and the stacking of evil things brings about misery for many. And there is only 1 life and you have to live it to the best of your abilities.

Yes, that places "God" as an omnipotent self-absorbed bully outside of the realm of religion and puts God more as being the collective idea of what we consider to be good, which can only come in hindsight. I like this idea better that God exists in our history, but it evolved from within our societies and worshipping a god is living up to the ideals of that society. Hence why the Bible is really a mis-mash of various Gods with different personalities over the ages.

37

serena williams

by FreeFallin in

not really a scandal, but serena williams doing the crip walk on national tv wtf .

Anony Mous

Sounds like Liam is in a spiritually weak congregation. Just needs 1 shakeup from a strict CO and how many people would fall in line? That's what the GB is most concerned about, they don't care you have 200 people in your congregation, they only need the ones that are contributing and those are the strict ones that lay the heavy load on others.

Read some of my and other stories here from the past. Not even that long ago, my two eldest wear the scars and one of them is not even an adult yet, the other just barely. You think that doesn't happen in your congregation? You have blinders.

37

serena williams

by FreeFallin in

not really a scandal, but serena williams doing the crip walk on national tv wtf .

Anony Mous

@liam: your experience depends strongly on your congregation. Even back in the day, the foreign language congregations were like that, but there are plenty of others that are still very strict.

Also, you are speaking as an inactive youngster, once you get deeper into it, get older, speak against the organization, commit a “sin”, your experience will change quickly.

37

serena williams

by FreeFallin in

not really a scandal, but serena williams doing the crip walk on national tv wtf .

Anony Mous

If you don’t see what the problem is (according to JW) perhaps read the lyrics:

https://www.justjared.com/2025/02/10/not-like-us-lyrics-kendrick-lamars-drake-diss-track-goes-viral-again-after-super-bowl-2025-performance/

23

Jehovah provides Javier a part-time job

by RULES & REGULATIONS in

the watchtower—study edition | march 2025. keep walking by faith.

7 note how javier, a brother in south america, saw the need to walk by faith.

he says: “i had applied for a prestigious job that would double my salary and provide considerable personal satisfaction.” however, javier had the deep desire to pioneer.

Anony Mous

The thing with part time jobs is that they are very few and far between and often unstable. It’s for companies that don’t need a full time person to do some menial task. It’s mostly intended as a “side job” like Uber/Lyft to complement your full time job and work a little harder to make some extra money while you are young, so it often doesn’t have the same benefits and protections, especially outside the US.

As others have said, most of the “millions now living” from the cover of that magazine have already died and if you were a child like me when that magazine was published, you’re now having children of your own entering the workforce and maybe you even have grandchildren. If I had done that, worked part time for all these years, I couldn’t afford kids, I couldn’t afford a house, I couldn’t afford savings for pensions, I wouldn’t have learned on the job as I have. Keep em poor and stupid.

12

Miscarriage myths amongst JW

by Anony Mous in

so i am having these discussions about children etc and there are witness ties and family history in these discussions.

i got the feeling having this discussion that they seemed to imply somehow it was ‘the parent’s fault’ for having a miscarriage.

whether it was domestic violence, or the mother did something wrong themselves.

Anony Mous

@biahi: this was official doctrine because you run into logistical issues resurrecting the pre-born into the womb. They changed that to “we don’t know how but Jehovah may come up with a solution” pretty recently, I would say late 90s, early 2000s after test tube babies and frozen embryos were common.

4

Trump 'spiritual advisor' says Jesus never broke immigration laws

by SydBarrett in

jw
friends

paula white said, “yes, jesus did live in egypt for three-and-a-half years.

but he was not an illegal immigrant.

if he had broken the law then he would have been sinful and he would not have been our messiah.” well, there you go.

Anony Mous

Well, yeah, Rome was pretty well known for its open immigration:

But in the fifth century the Romans lost control of the immigration process. Armies were sent to the Middle East to counter a hostile, newly invigorated Persia, leaving the West open. The Germanic tribes were allowed in, but once inside the empire they were not assimilated but retained their cultural and political identities, eventually combining to form armies within its borders that the Romans could no longer overcome.

(Peter Heather, The Fall of the Roman Empire, Pan Books, 2005, 158ff.)

12

Miscarriage myths amongst JW

by Anony Mous in

so i am having these discussions about children etc and there are witness ties and family history in these discussions.

i got the feeling having this discussion that they seemed to imply somehow it was ‘the parent’s fault’ for having a miscarriage.

whether it was domestic violence, or the mother did something wrong themselves.

Anony Mous

Forgot all about the Bathsheba story, or the story where the priest gives basically an abortion (magic potion) to people that are under suspicion of adultery and if you are an adulterer, you have a miscarriage, if not the child survives. These weren’t backwater witnesses though, this is educated, relatively middle class in the city.

But looking through some of the articles, I can see where people may get the impression:

Divorce, unwanted pregnancy, sexually transmitted disease, loss of trust or respect—all of these may be the sad, unavoidable consequences of sin. Recall that even after forgiving David for his sins in connection with Bath-sheba and Uriah, Jehovah did not protect David from the disastrous consequences that followed - 2 Samuel 12:9-12

Note here that the extended story then basically says God killed the baby

And Jehovah struck the child whom U·riʹah’s wife had borne to David, and he became sick …
On the seventh day the child died

Or how about this gem:

In this particular case of David and Bath-sheba neither of them had a right to the child and so there was no injustice in their being deprived of it. Besides, as an uncircumcised, unnamed infant it had not as yet developed any personality pattern or consciousness so as to appreciate life.

12

Miscarriage myths amongst JW

by Anony Mous in

so i am having these discussions about children etc and there are witness ties and family history in these discussions.

i got the feeling having this discussion that they seemed to imply somehow it was ‘the parent’s fault’ for having a miscarriage.

whether it was domestic violence, or the mother did something wrong themselves.

Anony Mous

Children, enemies (video on jw.org) from 25:00-25:30 you can see the governing body address children as enemies of God

Think about it - we're not born as friends of God.

Because we're born as sinful offsprings of Adam.

Actually if you think about it, we are born as enemies of god.

Sometimes you hear people say of a little baby, " look at that little angel".

But more accurate would be to say - "look at that little enemy of god."

5

Pinata's vs Birthday's - classic JW hypocrisy

by joey jojo in

i vaguely knew that the pinata had some kind of pagan origin and i assumed that having a pinata at a jw party was frowned on by the b0rg.

however, despite its blatant pagan origins, apparently i was wrong.. the 22 september, 2003 awake states that the aztecs would smash a clay pot full of 'treasures' in honour of the god huitzilopochtli's birthday.

spanish missionaries simply switched the pot for the pinata during the christian conversion of the aztecs.

Anony Mous

Birthday’s weren’t really celebrated in history, except for really rich or powerful people. Children’s birthdays originated in early 1800s Germany and spread. This was much similar to Christmas and other celebrations for kids, it practically was the Industrial Revolution that caused the practice to spread, suddenly people were wealthy enough and kids didn’t have to work enough to make it affordable.